• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Wytchery: A Gothic Cabinet of Curiosities and Mysteries

Wytchery: A Gothic Cabinet of Curiosities and Mysteries

A collection of gothic horror stories, urban legends, ghosts, haunted houses & other curiosities

  • Curiosity Cabinet
    • Journal
    • The Witch’s Gardener
      • A Grimoire
      • Plants
      • What’s blooming?
    • Pagans & Witches
    • Gothic Horror
    • Real Ghost Stories
    • History
      • Daily Life
      • Towns and Villages
      • sites
      • Events and Celebrations
      • Issues
  • Travels
  • Author
  • Hello
  • Shop
    • Shirts & Hoodies
    • Mugs
    • Books
    • Art Prints
  • Cart
  • Show Search
Hide Search

The Spooner House, Plymouth, Massachusetts: A haunting in America’s hometown

The Spooner House, Plymouth, Massachusetts

In August of 2005, a group of workmen were hired to do repairs at the Spooner House in Plymouth, Massachusetts and upon arriving, knocked at the door. A little girl in colonial period costume opened it, which surprised no one as the more than 262 year-old house has been a museum for over 50 years. They got busy with their task, and soon along comes the curator, who curious, asks how they got in. The foreman shrugs and says the little girl let them in.

“What little girl,” the curator asked. The workmen led the curator to the room which the little girl had entered, only to find it, as well as the rest of the house, empty. The workmen, not used to encountering ghosts in broad daylight, packed it in and left.

Little girl ghosts creep me out. It could be leftovers from seeing the Shining years ago. It could be that little girl ghosts are just creepy.

By all accounts, the ghost of Abigail Townsend is a friendly little spirit, and shouldn’t frighten anyone. Abigail was a tiny thing when the Spooner family took her into the family home in the mid 18th century. The house itself, is one of the oldest houses on one of the oldest streets in America. Plymouth of course was founded by the Pilgrims in 1620, and today bills itself as America’s Hometown. Built about 1749 on North Street, just one street over from Leyden Street, where according to tradition the pilgrims built their settlement, five generations of Spooners called the two story house their home. Originally constructed for the widow Hannah Jackson, the first Spooner to take up residence was a successful business man and patriot of the American revolution, Deacon Ephraim Spooner. It stayed in the family until the death of James Spooner in 1954. It was James who willed the house and all its furnishings to be turned into a museum. Today it contains over 200 years of original furnishing, giving one a sense of how life has changed, or perhaps how little life has changed in Plymouth over the past two centuries.

And perhaps it’s haunted by James as well. Music has been heard coming from the house when it was quite empty, and James was well-known as a patron of the musical arts. But alas, it’s the creepy little kid ghosts that get all the publicity, and so the music is attributed to Abigail. Though when you think of it, that makes no sense at all, as it’s unlikely an eight year-old girl could have been very musical, and there were no stereos in the 18th century.

Abigail fell victim to a tooth infection, dying in an upstairs room of the Spooner House. There was no penicillin in those days, the infection spread and there was nothing to do about it, but try to comfort the little girl in what must have been an agonizing death.

Since then she’s been seen periodically, peering from the windows, rustling the bushes along the alley, even occasionally standing at the corner of the house. But more recently she’s seem to have become more active. Or perhaps the stories just get more publicity.

According to Emily Wilcox, writing for GateHouse News Service, a woman who used to live next door to the Spooner House awoke in the middle of the night to find Abigail standing at the foot of her bed.

As I said, creepy.

Writing in Haunted Massachusetts Thomas D’Agostino relates how on a Colonial Lantern Tour of Plymouth, outside the Spooner House, a woman felt someone touching her shoulder. Turning, she saw a little girl who said “I have to go now” and promptly vanished. The group was amazed at the special effects, until the tour guide assured them that there was no special effects.

The Colonial Lantern Tour has had other bizarre experiences at the Spooner House. Lights have been spotted going from room to room upstairs at night, such as that of a candle or lantern, and once a tourist asked the guide to shine the light between a crack in some shutters so she might have a look inside. The guide obliged, and the shutters flew open to reveal a woman standing there, staring back, who then vanished as the onlookers fled.

Getting there:

1749 Spooner House, 27 North Street, Plymouth, MA

Haunted Plymouth: The macabre history of Plymouth, Mass., where Pilgrim and native American spirits haunt side by side

Separating fact from fiction about the Pilgrims and the first Thanksgiving

Living history at haunted Plymouth’s Plimoth Plantation

You might find these interesting

  • Newbury Massachusetts and the Pierce Tomb: Dancing with the dead on Old Burial Hill

    The Pierce Tomb in Newburyport Massachusetts has been the victim of various vandals with a…

  • Tales From Head of the Harbor & St. James Part IV: A True Ghost Story from Head of the Harbor

    Carman-White House, St. James, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York Top: The Carman-White House. Samuel…

  • Yorktown Ghost Stories: Colonial era ghosts still haunt the streets of this landmark village of the American Revolution

    The Nelson House is an imposing edifice by anyone's standards. Three stories tall and on…

  • Barnstable Village Haunted History Tours: A delightfully creepy Halloween stroll

    Colonial Era Architecture: The Old Jail, Barnstable, Cape Cod, Massachusetts The Old Gaol (The Old…

  • The Beechwood Inn, Barnstable Massachusetts: ghostly encounters in the shower

    Haunted Hotels and B&Bs: Rose Room, Beechwood Bed and Breakfast, Barnstable, County Barnstable, Cape Cod,…

  • Tales from St. James and Head of the Harbor II: Hard Candy and Ghosts at St. James General Store

    St. James General Store, St. James, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York "I don't like…

Tweet
Share151
151 Shares

September 11, 2011 By gothiccurios 7 Comments

Filed Under: Haunted Houses and Buildings, Plymouth, The best in haunted travel tips, True Ghost Stories Tagged With: haunted house pictures, haunting stories, pictures of haunted houses, real ghost story, real haunted stories

About the author and artist

The haunted, macabre, the downright peculiar ….the curiously gothic world of Todd Atteberry

 

Gothic horror stories, haunted travelogues, a healthy dose of witchcraft, paganism, stone circles and ancient trackways.

Meet Todd

The Witch’s Gardener …

A look at witch’s garden plants, ideas, resources, moon gardens, folklore, herbalism and life with the witch’s gardener.

Enter The Garden

Gothic Travels …

Haunted travelogues, where to visit, where to stay, the history and truth behind the legends

Explore

Memento Mori

Remember you are mortal. T-shirts, hoodies and gaiters, Premium fabrics and fit, eco friendly and ethically sourced.
Wear Memento Mori

Visit the shop …

Offering Wyrd and Wanton T-Shirts, Long Sleeve Tees and Hoodies, Books and Fine Art Prints … Literary love tokens for children of the night.


Lets go shopping!

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Andrew Tocci

    January 22, 2013 at 11:43 pm

    My name is Andrew Tocci with R.T.S Paranormal Investigations , we are currently traveling around New England for our 2013 Haunted Paranormal Tour and we would love the chance to investigate such a unique and historic Estate. We Operate out of Wrentham, Mass. We would really love to Include the Spooner House to are 2013 tour. If Given the Opportunity to conduct a paranormal Investigation at the Estate , R.T.S offers Free Advertisement on our Website , also R.T.S is willing to make a Small donation to the Estate , or a Local Charity. Maybe at your convenience we can set up a small meeting.

    I look forward to working with you on this request.

    Andrew Tocci- Founder

    Reply
  2. anonymus

    October 21, 2013 at 12:10 am

    wow. Im using this for a halloween story!

    Reply
  3. Mariah Lyden

    October 29, 2016 at 4:05 am

    I’m so sad because she had to go through all that and her mom was so rude to her.Its so sad because she never got to see her dad that long and her mom blamed him disappearing spool rude!!!!??

    Reply
  4. Kyson

    March 26, 2017 at 7:35 pm

    Poor little girl ? I would love to go to her house and hug her right now ? She is very friendly

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Episode 8 – Thanksgiving Special: The Ghosts of Plymouth Rock says:
    November 20, 2017 at 8:35 pm

    […] Abigail’s Ghost: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aGnlAZUrOcA https://www.gothichorrorstories.com/true-ghost-stories/the-spooner-house-plymouth-ma-a-haunting-in-a… Gurnet Lighthouse: […]

    Reply
  2. The macabre history and ghosts of haunted Plimoth, Mass says:
    November 19, 2018 at 12:26 am

    […] The Spooner House, Plymouth, Massachusetts: A haunting in America’s hometown […]

    Reply
  3. The truth about Thanksgiving and the creation of an American myth - A Gothic Cabinet of Curiosities and Mysteries says:
    September 30, 2019 at 5:00 pm

    […] The Spooner House, Plymouth, Massachusetts: A haunting in America’s hometown […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more

Haunted Travels A witch's garden Get Connected

Footer

Copyright © 2021

Keep In Touch

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Thank you for visiting

Want curiosities in your inbox?

Sign up to receive emails from A Gothic Curiosity Cabinet.